Linn Steward

July 2022

Volume 76, No. 6

Group Discussion
Join the Discussion right arrow
Is there a viable context in which NOVA makes some sense? And could that inform sensible modifications? Share your thoughts by joining the discussion on IFT Connect.
Chef prepping food
Chef prepping food

Global rates of obesity continue to increase. Government policy makers and health-care professionals are desperate to do something. Anything. And NOVA, a crude but useful tool used by nutrition researchers to map chronic health conditions to degree of processing, is attracting attention.

There’s plenty to criticize about NOVA. Its four food classification groups are at best squishy, at worst downright arbitrary. And significant gaps of logic are emerging now that food scientists and nutrition researchers are starting to take a serious look.

Still, I believe Carlos Monteiro is onto something, and I’d like to explain how I came to that conclusion.

Monteiro, now a professor in the Department of Nutrition at the University of São Paulo’s School of Public Health, started his career in the 1970s working as a young pediatrician in poor rural villages and urban slums of Brazil’s largest city. Over the next three decades, he was able to map eating habits and chronic disease, and his observations became the basis for the NOVA food classification system.

Complex is how I’d describe my attraction to NOVA.

I currently work in recipe analysis and food labeling, but despite my analytic inclination, I’m a foodie at heart and love to cook. From time to time, I’ve been privileged to work with some wonderful chefs, and it’s during these sessions that I came to realize the appeal NOVA has for people who cook.

NOVA’s inherent “squishiness,” which makes academics, food scientists, and my fellow dietitians so crazy, doesn’t bother chefs. The best cooks understand the complexity of simple cooking. They start with fresh ingredients. Freshness depends on seasons, localities, climate, and other variables. Fresh ingredients are exactly what gets classified in NOVA as Group 1, minimally processed foods.

Placing fats, sugars, and salt in NOVA Group 2, processed culinary ingredients, also makes sense because that’s how chefs cook. Particular choices or combinations always depend on culture, tradition, and personal taste. As for NOVA Group 3, processed foods, every culture has developed its own unique set of traditionally processed ingredients. Up until recently, adding salt, sugar, or fat was how foods were kept safe.

"All I need to do is take off my analytic hat and put on my chef’s cap and NOVA starts to make sense to me too."

- Linn Steward, RDN, recipe analyst and food and nutrition consultant , Gourmet Metrics

Once I take off my analytic hat and put on my chef’s cap, NOVA starts to make sense to me. The subjective experience of eating. Tastes. Smells. Sounds. Joys. Pleasures. Textures. Terroir. Traditions. Cultures.

When I put my analytic hat back on, I see the arbitrariness, absurdity, and disorderliness of the classification system. And I agree that until researchers are able to find causal mechanisms, the extent to which industrially formulated foods are to blame for the dramatic rise in obesity rates remains a matter of speculation.

I am not a food scientist. But I have spent 30 years working in weight loss and studying the science of nutrition as it applies to metabolic health. Experience has taught me that the behavioral approach to weight loss only works for some people, so we must look elsewhere. Obesity is also a complex issue, but I think it’s likely that researchers will identify aspects of food processing that are a contributing factor.

Food is messy. It doesn’t always fit neatly into boxes or groups or graphs or spreadsheets. My business is based on reducing the radiant complexity of food to listing nutrients on a label or running numbers on a recipe or researching a health claim for a client. But I know those numbers don’t come close to capturing our collective human culinary legacy.

Eating is a subjective experience based on individual occurrences. I never ate a traditional Brazilian home-cooked meal in 1980s São Paulo, but I believe that meal served a need that was valid. I am attracted to NOVA because the classification system acknowledges that food is more than just the sum of its nutrient parts. 

The expressed in Dialogue are those of the author.

In This Article

  1. Diet and Health

About the Author

Linn Steward, RDN, is a recipe analyst and food and nutrition consultant ([email protected]).

Digital Exclusives right arrow

Yes NOVA Is Flawed But It Can Not Be Ignored

Job Ubbink and Allen Levine posit that the NOVA food classification system is flawed, but it draws attention to the fact that many processed foods are not healthfully formulated.

Reaching Gen Z On Their Terms

Speaking as a part of a Tuesday Scientific & Technical Forum on consumer mistrust, Center for Food Integrity’s Roxi Beck highlighted some recent research on Gen Z’s purchase behavior.

Why Regenerative Agriculture Matters to Brands

Three passionate advocates for regenerative agriculture laid out the challenges and opportunities it presents in a Monday Business FIRST session.

One Company’s ‘Food Waste’ is Another’s Profitable Reuse

Byproducts of agriculture and food processing written off as “waste” can be profitably and sustainably reused as other food products, according to panelists at a featured session on Monday at IFT FIRST.

Food Technology Articles right arrow

Reflections by Richard Waycott and News From Ingredient Companies

News and new product information from food industry suppliers, including a Q&A with Richard Waycott of the Almond Board Of California.

Equipped for Food Safety

In this column, the author describes the regulatory and food safety considerations of utilizing principles of sanitary equipment design.

Top 4 Ingredient Trends from IFTs Food Expo

A team of Food Technology editors visited the IFT FIRST Food Expo floor in search of the latest ingredient innovations—and found four top trends that are exciting both industry innovators and consumer palates.

Making Sense of Consumer Complexity

Connecting the dots between behavioral research insights and product innovation is a labor of love for Dave Lundahl.

Making a Successful Co-Manufacturing Match

Finding the right co-manufacturing partner can be challenging, but it can also be a smart business strategy. Here’s a look at some of the ins, the outs, and the how-tos.

Recent Brain Food right arrow

A New Day at the FDA

IFT weighs in on the agency’s future in the wake of the Reagan-Udall Report and FDA Commissioner Califf’s response.

Members Say IFT Offers Everything You Need to Prepare for an Uncertain Future

Learn how IFT boosts connections, efficiencies, and inspiration for its members.

More on the FDA's Food Traceability Final Rule

In a new white paper, our experts examine the FDA’s Food Traceability Final Rule implications—and its novel concepts first proposed by IFT.