Larry Keener

Group Discussion
Join the Discussion right arrow
Does your organization have a proactive DEI strategy or program in place? Share your thoughts by joining the discussion on IFT Connect.

scientistsSome have said that instituting the principles of diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) in the workplace, out of compulsion, results in mediocrity, not meritocracy. However, in the absence of diversity and inclusion, it is exceedingly difficult in most human endeavors to proclaim that someone or something merits designation as “the best.” In other words, without diversity and inclu­sion, meritocracy itself is a meritless myth, and any merit bestowed cannot be deemed equitable.

Science, resplendent in objec­tivity, is not immune to these pernicious failings when it comes to a lack of DEI principles in our workplaces. Years ago, I was told by my university advisor that my pursuit of a degree in science “was (for an African-American man) socially deviant behavior.” My inclu­sion in the program challenged the contemporary orthodoxy and the closely guarded cultural hegemony within the sciences. The diversity that I brought to the program was received with a resounding chill.

I know others with similar stories.

I would argue that the presence of differences within a given com­munity (diversity) and the practice of ensuring that people feel a sense of belonging (inclusion), coupled with ensuring that processes and pro­grams are impartial, fair, and provide equal possible outcomes for every individual (equity), is foundational to creating an environment in which meritocracy, not mediocrity, thrives.

Examples abound. For instance, I think most will agree that pugilism is the ultimate measure of meritocracy. Mano y mano, as it were. I don’t think, however, that there are many who subscribe to the notion that Jack Johnson’s inclusion in boxing ushered in an era of mediocrity. Rather, I think, most would agree that his inclusion added diversity to the sport, which may have exposed mediocrity masquerading as the champion.

There are countless stories about American icons that illustrate this point. Despite segregated working conditions at NASA, Katherine Johnson and her team were instru­mental in the monumental success of America’s manned space flight program. John Glenn, the celebrated astronaut, did not see their work as mediocre. Rosalind Franklin played a pivotal role in elucidating the struc­tural geometry of DNA. Yet, because of her gender, her brilliant contribu­tions to the field are underreported. In the world of tennis, thanks to Althea Gibson’s courage and master­ful game, we now celebrate Venus and Serena—the antithesis of mediocrity. And, during World War II, the U.S. government made Herculean efforts to desegregate and make the armed services more inclusive. Gradually, honors and promotion to positions of leadership were opened to all service members. These actions resulted in exceptional leaders, including General Colin Powell, General Lloyd Austin, and Admiral Linda Fagan. No mediocrity in these ranks.

In a pluralist society, the dom­inant group frequently seeks to invalidate the contributions of its minorities. In the United States, this is often the case for women, people of color, and other marginalized groups. Advancing the idea that compulsory DEI results in mediocrity is a form of societal invalidation, and its aim is to maintain a sort of cultural hegemony while simultaneously preserving the preferred socio­economic order among its various subgroups. The easiest means for maintaining and sustaining cultural hegemony is through segregation and exclusion. When the field of participants for any organized activity is the exclusive domain of the dominant group, that group can feign an appearance of superiority.

Historically, efforts to preserve cultural hegemony within the sci­ences have been highly effective. For decades, women and people of color were summarily excluded from its ranks. The face of science in the United States is still predominantly that of a male person of European descent. Not an Asian, not an African, and certainly not a woman.

Achieving diversity often is a challenge due to trepidation and fear of fraternity with the unknown. Achieving an inclusive organization requires deliberate actions in bringing it to fruition. Diversity and inclusion enable an institution or a society to overcome mediocrity. The true measure of a society’s greatness can­not be ascertained when multitudes of citizens are excluded. Judging mer­itocracy under conditions of exclusion is the highest form of folly.

The opinions expressed in Dialogue are those of the author. 

About the Author

Larry Keener, CFS, PA, an internationally recognized microbiologist and process authority in the food industry, is president and CEO of International Product Safety Consultants Inc. ([email protected]).

Digital Exclusives right arrow

10 Food Trend Predictions for 2022

The editors at Food Technology magazine, published by the Institute of Food Technologists (IFT), have announced their predictions for the hottest food trends for 2022.

When Science Follows Technology

While canning is commonplace today, for that generation of food technologists it was a paradigmatic example of the power of science to change food for the better.

Ingredient Companies Seek Sodium Reduction Solutions

In October 2021, the FDA released new voluntary guidance on sodium reduction with the overarching goal of reducing consumption by 12% over the next two-and-a-half years.

North American Consumers Get Comfortable With Cannabis

What changes have occurred in the way Canadians perceive cannabis since it was legalized there in 2018? How do Canadian and U.S. consumers of cannabis and edibles compare?

Food Technology Articles right arrow

Extending ADM From Seed to Fork

It’s a new era for the agribusiness giant, and Leticia Gonçalves, president of global foods, is well equipped to help guide the company’s reinvention as a more consumer-focused, value-added organization.

The Inflation Diet

An infographic presenting facts and figures on how inflation impacts grocery choices.

IFT Perspectives From the White House Conference

IFT 2022-2023 President Chris Downs discusses IFT’s response to the White House Conference on Hunger Nutrition and Health.

Outlook 2023: Technology Trends

The second in a series of three trend articles for the year ahead tracks what food and beverage technologies are trending in 2023 and beyond.

The Bountiful Promise of Indoor Farming

High-tech growing systems are transforming agricultural production, yielding increasingly fruitful harvests in tightly controlled environments.

Recent Brain Food right arrow

A Roadmap for Combating Food Insecurity and Promoting Health

IFT’s Anna Rosales attended the White House Conference on Hunger, Nutrition, and Health. Here are her key takeaways.

Bringing Their True Selves to Work

Two IFT members reflect on how resource groups help them promote diversity and inclusion on the job.

ICYMI: Our Most-Popular Business FIRST Conversations Available Online

Tune in to the IFT FIRST on-demand content channel and hear from experts and innovators who are making big impacts.

Packing a School Lunch? Keep Safety Top of Mind 

A few simple steps are all it takes to keep school lunches not only tasty but safe, says IFT’s food safety expert Sara Bratager.